Last night (April 30th) I attended a public presentation in Troy on oil and gas production in Michigan put on by the DEQ and DNR. The presenters were Tom Hoane from the MDNR’s Mineral Management Division and Harold Fitch, DEQ’s Supervisor of Wells.
Although the agencies tried to make it a general discussion on oil and gas, the presentation and most of the questions from the audience focused on the controversial topic of fracking….and it was clear the local police and the agencies were prepared for potential trouble as there were six conservation officers and three police cruisers in the parking lot. (A clear difference from other DNR/DEQ presentations I’ve attended in the past!) Despite the controversial topic, decorum was maintained and there were no disturbances.
The issue of fracking has been getting a lot of press recently but companies have been doing it in Michigan in a lesser but somewhat comparable form since 1952. Since that time more than 10,000 fracking wells have been installed in Michigan, mostly in a geological formation called the “Antrim Shale.” Since 1925 a total of 60,000 oil and gas wells have been drilled; of those 4,500 have been for oil, 11,000 have been for gas and 3,000 have been for gas storage.
About 80% of the wells drilled in Michigan (and the U.S.) recently have been fracking wells and the natural (methane) gas produced from those wells have caused the price of natural gas to plummet in the U.S. to $2 per million British thermal units (compared to $10 in the U.K.) According to some analysts (as noted in this recent Washington Post article), this gas boom is fueling a revival in American manufacturing – something we desperately need in this country.
Naturally, this flush of inexpensive gas doesn’t come without weighty public policy issues, and the issues the attendees focused on during last night’s forum are the same being raised elsewhere in the country: contamination of groundwater aquifers and depletion of fresh groundwater.
According to the DEQ, vertical fracking wells use between 50,000 to 100,000 gallons while some horizontal wells (like most of the current wells) can use up to 20 million gallons of water. In comparison, total water withdrawals in Michigan in 2010 amounted to 267 billion gallons. (However, the DEQ admitted that most of the later amount returns to the environment while the millions of gallons of water used in fracking are permanently removed from and never return to the watershed due to the contaminants in it.) Although groundwater used for oil and gas production are exempt from Michigan’s water withdrawal legislation, the Supervisor of Wells issued Well Instruction 1-2011 which allows the DEQ to use Michigan’s water withdrawal assessment tool to determine if a proposed gas well will have an adverse impact on stream flow. If such an impact is identified, the DEQ does not issue a permit.
The DEQ also asserted that claims about “flaming tap water” (as seen on YouTube) due to fracking are false and the instances where it has occurred are not due to the fracturing of bedrock but methane leaking around improper well casings (or methane naturally seeping into an overlying aquifer). According to the DEQ, Michigan’s well casing requirements prevent this from happening. In Michigan, drillers are required to use several corrosion resistant metal casings (conductor, surface, intermediate, and production casings) that are cemented together to seal off the well from the surrounding environment. (A diagram of the typical well is depicted to the right.)gas well
If these requirements are followed, according to the DEQ, the risk of a well contaminating groundwater is very low.
All in all I think the DEQ/DNR did a good job at trying to explain the issues and point out some facts to ameliorate the public’s concerns but I don’t think the issues, especially the water withdrawal issue, will be going away any time soon. As with everything, the goal will be trying to find the right balance.